I understand you very well, but that does not mean that I cannot differ.

I changed the shortcut with version 1.6, because a number of users (more than 10) wrote that holding down the Command key is not practical for them, because the key cannot be released quickly enough and so BetterZip almost always starts a direct extraction.

I am a mouse user myself, so I never noticed the problem in real life situations, but I tried it and it was nearly impossible to release the keys in a timely manner. On the other hand, you are so far the only one to ask for the old modifier keys.

Of course, you can go for another product, although I really hate to lose users, but as far as I know, they don't have this feature at all.